Tempers and emotions run high in the U.S. over the slaughtering of horses. The process of killing them is highly scrutinized for being inhumane, but the alternative may be just as bad.
A bill passed through Congress on November 18th lifted a five-year ban on slaughtering horses for meat. There is widespread support to try to stop this from happening.
The Humane Society has started a horse slaughter petition. “It is vital that we renew our push to pass the American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act that will prohibit horse slaughter from returning to the U.S. and end the export of American horses for slaughter,” said the Humane Society in a statement on their website.
Terry Shine, runs a horse rescue operation in Live Oak, FL. “It’s awful, just awful. I’ve seen the videos. They took videos in the kill plants from 2004-2007,” said Shine. “The horses cry. They use a bolt gun to kill them and sometimes it doesn’t work. They hung a colt up by his hind legs while he was still alive. It’s all in the video.”
Though, the process may not be that humane, it pales in comparison to what the horses are going through because of the ban. The country is flooded with horses that don’t receive the proper care they deserve. Horses starve and suffer from poor treatment. And the ban isn’t saving all of them. They are still being slaughtered only now they have to be hauled long distances for slaughter in either Mexico or Canada.
“Ending the kill market made it so you can’t give a horse away. People are letting ‘em loose. I sold two horses at the cow sale for $54, and that wasn’t each, that was for both of them. Didn’t cover the cost of having the vet pull the Coggins test so I could transport them,” said Vinnie Seccafico, old horse-trader from the 60’s and 70’s, horse breaker, trainer and farrier.
PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) founder, Ingrid Newkirk, supports the decision to lift the ban. “There was a rush to pass a bill that said you can’t slaughter them anymore in the United States. But the reason we didn’t support it, which sets us almost alone, is the amount of suffering that it created exceeded the amount of suffering it was designed to stop,” she said on the Christian Science Monitor.
This is a good development for the horse market and for horse owners. New and more humane slaughtering factories will be opening up in the U.S. bringing back lost businesses. Nebraska, North Dakota, Georgia and Missouri are considering opening slaughter plants. “My boy saw it on the internet. Got to get out there and buy me some horses while the prices are still cheap,” said Calvin Yates, a long-time cowboy and horse trader from St. Cloud, FL.
It’s a tough call and a controversial subject. Everyone loves the thought of a wild horse running free across the open prairie. But the plain fact of the matter is there are too many horses right now in the United States. And the reason the market is flooded is the bill that shut down the killer plants.